It is tempting to chase every deal, but a second store only helps if the savings are bigger than what the extra trip costs you. Here is a way to decide.
What the experts suggest
Canada's Food Guide recommends comparing the unit price on labels to see which product costs less, comparing store brands and name brands, and using flyers. In stores that offer price matching, you can use flyers to match the sale prices of other stores. Saskatchewan Health Authority materials also suggest checking flyers and using in-store or store apps.
A simple method
- Pick a main store close to home that has a good price on most of your usual items.
- List the items where another store is clearly cheaper, especially things you buy in quantity, such as meat, dairy, or staples.
- Add up the savings. Compare the total saved against the cost of the extra trip, including fuel and your time.
- Only go if the savings are meaningful. If the gap is small, stay at your main store.
An example, for illustration only
Imagine a second store would save you $6 on your list, but the extra drive costs about $4 in fuel and takes half an hour. That is a very small gain for the effort. If the savings were $20, it would be a different decision. Your numbers will differ based on distance, vehicle, and prices.
Ways to save without a second trip
- Ask about price matching at your main store, and bring or show the flyer.
- Stock up on non-perishables when the second store has a great price, so you don't need to go back often.
- Combine trips with errands you are making anyway.
- Build meals around your main store's sales so you need fewer items from elsewhere.
The bottom line
There is no single right answer, because distance and prices differ for everyone. Compare totals, not just single items. ShoppedOut does the comparison for you by showing the lowest basket total across nearby stores, so you can see whether a second stop is worth it.
Sources
- Health Canada, Canada's Food Guide, "Healthy eating on a budget": https://food-guide.canada.ca/en/tips-for-healthy-eating/healthy-eating-budget
- Saskatchewan Health Authority, "Getting the most out of your food budget": https://www.saskhealthauthority.ca/sites/default/files/2026-06/Handout-NFS-Most-Out-of-Your-Food-Budget.pdf
